By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
How should a plumber price a job?
A plumber prices well by pricing each item in the job separately, with labour, materials and markup already built in, rather than quoting a rate per hour. A hot water unit, a tap, a toilet, a rough-in and a fit-off each get their own price. There is no hourly rate left for a customer to hold up against the next plumber's quote, because the number simply does not exist in that form.
This matters because a customer ringing around for quotes on a bathroom renovation or a blocked drain is almost always comparing the one number every plumber gives out: the rate. Item pricing takes that number off the table entirely, so the comparison has to move to the actual work, not the wage.
Why does quoting an hourly rate lose the job before the plumber has even started?
Most owners who quote a rate per hour are handing the customer the easiest possible way to shop them against the next call. The rate is one number, it is simple to write down, and it is simple to compare, so the decision can be made before the plumber has explained anything about the job.
A burst pipe at eleven at night or a blocked drain backing up into a laundry does not care what the rate is, the customer just wants it fixed. But a bathroom renovation quote, a gas fitting job or a strata maintenance contract renewal gets compared on rate every time, and a plumber who leads with the rate has already put themselves in a line-up with every other plumber in the area.
Why can a quote total look profitable when some lines are actually losing money?
A plumber who prices a job line by line, hot water unit, tap, toilet, rough-in, fit-off, can have some lines paying well and others losing money, and never know it, because the business only ever looks at the total on the quote. The total can look fine while individual items are bleeding margin underneath it.
This is how a job can be quoted, invoiced, paid, and still leave the owner wondering where the money went. A compliance certificate line might be priced to cover the paperwork and the backflow test, but if the toilet or tap lines underneath it are priced on an old price list, the loss on those lines quietly eats the profit the certificate line was meant to protect.
How do you price items so an apprentice running the job doesn't lose money on it?
You price every item for the time and materials an average tradesperson in the business needs, not the fastest person on the tools. If the price list is built around the most efficient plumber in the business, it looks right on paper and loses money the moment an apprentice or a newer employee runs that same job.
This is where AI agents, software that does a piece of office work the way you would, using your prices, your wording and your rules, can hold the price list steady across every job sheet, every maintenance contract renewal with a strata manager or property manager, and every quote going out, regardless of which tradesperson on the crew is doing the pricing that week.
Picture a plumber whose pricing had been set job by job for years, varying between a homeowner, a builder and a property manager, with the rates never quite where they needed to be. Moving to one fixed price list across every type of customer, including builders, with a proper rate increase built in, and reviewing the cost of running the business every quarter instead of once a year, changes what the quote total is actually telling the owner.
What happens if the price list isn't reviewed when supplier costs or wages move?
A price list is not a one-off build, it is something that needs reviewing as supplier costs and wage rates move. If a hot water unit, a tap fitting or the materials for a backflow test go up and the price list is not updated, that increase comes straight off the plumber's margin without anyone noticing, job after job.
AI agents can sit across supplier invoices and the price list, flagging where a cost has moved since the price was last set, so the owner is working from a current picture rather than a list built a year or two ago. This is data first thinking: the price list is only ever as good as the data behind it, and that data changes every time a supplier price goes up or an award rate moves.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts from the plumber's own numbers, through the Trade Business Intelligence, looking at the blended margin across whole jobs rather than the total on a single quote. That is often where the real problem sits: not the quote itself, but which items inside it are quietly losing money.
Greg Allan built this from running his own trade business, and teaches that when a price moves and nobody notices, “that directly comes off of your profit margin.” The how, building and reviewing a price list that protects margin across every job type, is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member who is open minded, innovative and willing to share what they learn.
Looking for a business coach who starts from your numbers? Plumber Business Coach or every answer for plumbers.

