By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Why does a carpenter's pricing look fine on paper but still lose money?
Most carpenters price in more ways than almost any other trade. A day rate for a builder on one job, a fixed price for a deck or pergola on the next, then a fit-out broken into labour, timber and hardware lines on the one after that. On paper, with one markup sitting over the top of everything, the business can look busy and profitable while the real margin is quietly disappearing underneath.
The problem is that materials, travel between small jobs, and labour get bundled differently on every single job type. A subcontract day rate carries almost none of the material risk a fixed-price renovation does. A small fix-out with skirting, architrave and door hanging eats far more travel time relative to its value than a full week of framing on one site. When all of that gets squashed into one markup figure, the carpenter cannot see which jobs are actually paying and which ones are being carried by the others.
Why does one markup percentage not work across day rates, decks and fit-outs?
A single markup percentage treats every job as if it has the same mix of labour, materials and risk, and a carpentry business almost never does. The markup that works on a straightforward deck can quietly lose money on a fiddly fit-out, because the number on the quote never changes even though what sits underneath it has.
A carpenter charging a day rate to a builder is really selling time, with the builder carrying most of the material risk. A fixed-price pergola or deck means the carpenter is carrying timber, hardware and fixings as well as labour, and small jobs that eat travel time between sites chip away at margin that a flat markup never accounts for. Timber and hardware prices also move often, sometimes between one quote and the next, so a price list that was accurate a season ago can be wrong now even though the markup written on it looks the same.
What should a carpenter price job by job instead of a blanket markup?
Pricing each part of a job as its own priced item, with labour, materials and markup bundled into that line, means nothing gets left off the quote and the price stands up when a client or a builder questions it. It also means a fix-out, a deck and a fit-out can each carry the margin they actually need rather than sharing one average figure that suits none of them.
This matters most on the jobs carpenters price around themselves without realising it. A quote built on what the most efficient chippy on the crew could knock out runs short the moment it is handed to an apprentice or a second-year, because the materials and time were never really priced for the job, they were priced for the person. Pricing around what an average tradesperson or apprentice actually needs in time and materials protects the margin no matter who ends up on site.
Picture a carpenter whose quoting has always been slow and manual, built fresh each time from memory. With so many parts to a job, from the stud wall through to the last fixing, small materials like brackets and post caps get left off the quote and then turn up missing on site, costing a trip to the hardware store and a chunk of the day. A quoting checklist built for each type of job, covering every material down to the brackets and the posts, closes that gap before the job ever starts.
How do you check gross profit margin at the moment of quoting, not at tax time?
You check gross profit margin while you are still building the quote, line by line, not when the invoice is finally raised or the books are done at the end of the month. By the time a carpenter is looking at margin in the accounts, the job is finished and whatever was lost on timber, hardware or an underpriced day rate is already gone.
This is where your own job data matters more than a feeling about how a job went. A deck that felt like a good earner can be sitting on a thinner margin than a day rate job that felt ordinary, once travel, offcuts and the real hours an apprentice took are counted in. Checking margin at the point of quoting, and presenting the client with a good, better, best option that ends in a booked date rather than a price left sitting in an inbox, protects the number before the job starts rather than explaining it after.
How do AI agents fit into pricing for a carpentry business?
AI agents can take over the slow, repetitive part of pricing, building out the itemised quote from a checklist built around the job type, so nothing gets missed and the carpenter is not starting from a blank page every time. An AI agent is simply software that does a job the way the owner would do it, using their prices, their wording and their rules, not a generic calculator built for every trade.
This is data first thinking applied to quoting. Instead of a carpenter guessing at a price from memory or copying the last similar job, AI agents can hold the current timber and hardware rates, the checklist for that job type, and the carpenter's own markup rules, and build the quote from there. Where the job data shows a job type or a client keeps running thin, that is where the problem actually starts, and that is where the next quote needs to change, not just the markup on paper.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching, built by Greg Allan, starts from the carpenter's own job data through the Trade Business Intelligence rather than from a general rule about markups. It looks at which job types, which clients and which pricing methods, day rate, fixed price or itemised, are actually protecting margin and which ones only look like they are, so the fix goes in where the problem really starts. As Greg puts it, “one of the biggest mistakes we see people make is they price it around themselves doing it.” The how, the checklists, the agents and the pricing systems, is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member for every member, and that only works with owners who are open minded, innovative and willing to share.
Looking for a business coach who starts from your numbers? Carpenter Business Coach or every answer for carpenters.

