By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Why does a bathroom job that looked profitable on the quote still feel like it barely paid?
A tiler quotes a bathroom or ensuite at a square metre rate that covers tile, adhesive, membrane, grout and labour, and the job gets booked. Partway through the fix a box of large format tile turns up with hairline cracks, or cuts around a shower recess and tight falls run through more tile than allowed for, so another box of tile supply gets ordered. None of that extra cost gets written against the job itself.
It gets folded into “that's just tiling” and the owner moves on to the next renovation, assuming the numbers still look like the quote did on the day it was sent.
Where does the tile supply and breakage cost actually go once the job is finished?
Most tilers are too flat out on the tools, waterproofing, screeding and chasing falls to stop mid job and log every re-ordered box of tile supply against the job that caused it. A sole trader who says yes to every bathroom and splashback that comes through the phone, without writing down what extra tile supply or breakage each job actually cost, is trusting memory to do a job that belongs to the numbers.
Zoomed in week to week, every job still looks fine. Zoomed out over a quarter, the extra tile supply and breakage across a run of renovation and wet area jobs can quietly cancel out a month of hard graft on the tools, even though nothing felt wrong at the time it was happening.
What number actually tells a tiler the truth about a job's margin?
The number that matters is the gross profit margin on each job once tile supply, breakage, adhesive and membrane are counted as a direct cost, not the square metre rate you quoted at. That margin is the one to check the moment you quote, not something you look at once a month in the books.
When you present a bathroom or wet area job as good, better, best, with standard tile, large format and a feature wall each carrying their own tile supply and breakage allowance built in, you can close on the option that protects your margin and get a booked date there and then, rather than a quote sitting unanswered in someone's inbox.
How can AI agents stop tile supply and breakage slipping through unrecorded?
An AI agent is software that does a job the way you would, using your prices, your wording and your rules. On a tiling job, that means an agent sitting right where tile supply gets ordered or re-ordered, logging the extra cost against that bathroom or splashback job before it gets forgotten, instead of relying on you to remember it weeks later.
Data first, the agent works from your own job costing, not a general wastage guess that treats every trade the same way. AI agents built around how your jobs actually run can also flag when breakage on a run of large format work is creeping above what your square metre rate assumed, so you see it while there is still a job left to fix the pricing on, not after the quarter is already over.
What changes when a tiler sees the real cost of tile supply job by job?
Picture a tiler whose spring and summer renovation season was bringing in more bathroom and wet area jobs than the business could comfortably fit in. The work was flat out, but the margin on it was not reflecting how much was actually being asked of the crew, with breakage running higher on rushed fixes and extra tile supply getting ordered to cover it.
What changed was the pricing. The tiler set a separate rate for renovation and wet area work across the peak months, lifting the square metre rate to reflect the breakage and tile supply risk that peak season genuinely carried, and started explaining that gap to builders and homeowners on the phone as a reason to book outside the rush. Supply-only jobs, where the tiler handed over tile for someone else to fit and carried none of the control over breakage or waterproofing, stopped getting booked. What stayed was work the tiler fixed and could warranty themselves, membrane included.
Should a tiler keep using an off-the-shelf quoting app, or build something around how tile supply actually gets costed?
Some off-the-shelf quoting and invoicing apps work fine for you, and the data from your own jobs shows which ones earn their place. What those general tools rarely know is that large format tile needs different adhesive coverage than standard tile, that breakage runs higher on a feature splashback than a straight floor, or that a shower recess with tight falls eats more tile supply than a flat wet area.
Rather than renting software built for every trade at once, you can have systems built around your own jobs, your own suppliers and your own rates, so the materials cost of a bathroom or renovation job is tracked the way that job actually runs for you, not the way a generic app assumes it does.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts with the tiler's own job and finance data through the Trade Business Intelligence, not with a guess about what breakage should cost. It looks at gross profit margin job by job, where tile supply and breakage actually land, and whether that matches what the square metre rate assumed. Greg Allan has watched owners feel on top of a busy renovation season while the numbers tell a different story, and as he puts it, “when we don't actually zoom out, look at the financials, that's where you lost all of the profit.” The how, built from that starting point, is worked through inside the Academy, with members who are open minded, innovative and willing to share, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member.
Looking for a business coach who starts from your numbers? Tiler Business Coach or every answer for tilers.

