By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
What numbers actually tell you if the week made money?
Most earthmoving contractors check the bank balance or the week's invoices and call it a good week if the float went out, the excavator and bobcat were busy, and the tipper kept running to the tip. That picture can be completely wrong. Turnover and a healthy bank balance only show cash moving, not whether each machine actually made money on the hours it was paid for.
The number that tells the truth is machine hours, split into job efficiency and operational efficiency, checked for every excavator, bobcat and tipper separately rather than rolled into one happy-looking total for the whole earthmoving business. A trade business that blends a strong dry hire job with a slow wet hire day, or hides a day of floating plant between sites inside the worked column, can look flat out and still have quietly lost money on the days that mattered. The gap does not show up until the accountant produces the year's figures, and by then there is nothing left to fix for that week.
Why can a busy week on site still lose money for an earthmoving contractor?
A week can look full, machines running, tipping fees paid, operators on site from early, and still lose money, because the cost of running a machine gets counted for the whole day whether the hours were billable or not. Float time between sites, a breakdown that leaves an excavator idle, a wet day that stops trenching but still pays the operator, and routine servicing all cost the same in fuel and wages as a billable hour on a site cut.
A handful of strong dry hire jobs can carry the week on paper while those costs quietly eat the margin underneath. This is close to the mistake that caught out even the person who built the method behind this kind of weekly check: a year that looked like solid, steady work on the tools netted almost nothing once the figures were actually checked properly, because the losing days were hidden inside the busy-looking ones. That is why checking these numbers weekly, rather than waiting for one annual figure, matters so much to an earthmoving contractor.
What is job efficiency and why track it machine by machine?
Job efficiency is the hours a machine actually billed against the hours it was on the job, and you need to see it separately for the excavator, the bobcat, the tipper and anything else you run, not combined into one average. If your excavator was booked for a site cut all day but spent part of that time stuck behind a slow tipper or waiting on an attachment change, the billed hours and the actual hours on the job are not the same, and the gap is where the margin disappears.
Checked machine by machine, job efficiency tells you which plant earns its keep on which jobs, and which jobs are quietly running your best excavator at a loss while the invoice still says it was a good day.
What is operational efficiency and why does it expose float time?
Operational efficiency is the hours a machine billed against every hour it was paid for, including time spent floating between sites, waiting at the tip, in for servicing, or sitting through a wet day with the operator still on the clock. This is the number that catches what job efficiency alone cannot see.
An excavator can look perfectly efficient on the jobs it actually worked and still be losing money across the week once float time, fuel between sites and an operator paid through a wet day are counted in. Checking this number weekly, for every machine, shows you where the real cost of running your plant is being carried, and whether your dry hire and wet hire rates still cover it.
How do AI agents help an earthmoving contractor keep these numbers current?
An AI agent is software that does a job the way you would do it yourself, using your prices, your wording and your rules, so it can pull together each machine's billed hours against its actual and paid hours without you doing it by hand at the end of a long week. Instead of waiting for the bookkeeper to reconcile fuel, servicing and operator hours later, AI agents can keep job efficiency and operational efficiency current for every excavator, bobcat and tipper as the week runs.
This matters because a data first view of your own numbers, checked against your own jobs rather than guessed from memory or a feeling about how busy the week looked, is the only way to catch a losing machine before it runs another losing week. AI agents doing that non-billable tracking also means more of your time, and your office time, goes on quoting and running sites rather than chasing numbers after the fact.
What changes when an earthmoving contractor fixes pricing instead of chasing more jobs?
Picture an earthmoving contractor whose pricing had been set job by job, a different rate for a builder than for a civil client doing bulk earthworks, with no real link back to what the machine actually cost to run that day. The rates had drifted a long way from where they needed to be, and nobody had checked, because the invoices still went out and the bank balance still looked fine.
Moving to one fixed rate across every type of customer, including builders, with a meaningful increase built in from what the machine hours actually showed, changes the picture completely. From there, reviewing the cost of running the business every quarter, rather than once a year with the accountant, keeps the rate honest as fuel, servicing and tipping fees shift. The fix was never take on more work. It was the price per hour, checked against the real numbers, all along.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts from the earthmoving contractor's own job and machine data through the Trade Business Intelligence, not from a conversation about how busy the week felt. It looks at job efficiency and operational efficiency for every excavator, bobcat and tipper first, because that is usually where a margin problem actually starts, long before it shows up in a bank balance or an annual figure. Greg built this from running his own trade business, which is why he tells owners, “don't just rely on your accountant to tell you if you've done well every year.” The how, the systems and the build, is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member, and the Academy is for owners who are open minded, innovative and willing to share.

