By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Why does chasing more balcony and basement leads not always grow the business?
Most waterproofers pick up the phone when it rings and take the work, whether it is a balcony recoat before a settlement, a basement tanking job for a new build, or a remedial leak behind tiles in a bathroom. More leads feels like more business, but it is not the same thing. A waterproofing business can grow turnover while margin quietly drops, because balcony work, basement work and insurance work each carry different cost of materials, different cure time, different access difficulty and different warranty exposure.
A waterproofer who remembers the big job that paid well last year often chases more of the same, without checking whether that type of work is still as profitable once travel, defect call-backs and certificate obligations are counted. That memory is often out of date within a season of quoting. The season itself adds another layer: waterproofing work tends to peak around the building and renovation season, and the activity statement that follows that peak can catch a waterproofing business short on cash if the work chased during the rush was never checked for margin.
Is balcony work more profitable than basement work for most waterproofers?
Often, but not always, and the gap can close fast once the real cost of each job type is counted. Balcony work usually moves quicker: membrane and flashing detail, working alongside builders and tilers on a renovation or new build, with defect rectification demand fairly steady through the year. Basement work tends to run slower, with longer cure times, more substrate preparation, confined access, and a heavier compliance load around flood test results and certificates before a builder will sign off.
Insurance work on either can look attractive because it is steady, but the paperwork and the time waiting on approval can quietly eat the margin that looked fine on the quote. There is no rule that says balcony beats basement, or that insurance work beats either. The only honest answer sits in the business's own numbers, job by job, not in what felt like the better job last time.
How do you know which work to chase next?
You know by checking gross profit margin at the moment you are quoting the balcony recoat or the basement tanking job, not once a month when the books get done. If the margin on basement work has been sliding because cure times are blowing out or defect call-backs keep eating into warranty periods, that shows up at the point of quoting, long before it shows up in a profit and loss statement.
That data first check, margin at the point of quoting, is what turns deciding which work to chase into a decision instead of a guess. From there, presenting the client with good, better, best options, whether that client is a homeowner, a builder or a tiler calling on behalf of a client, and closing with an immediate booked date rather than a quote left sitting in an inbox, is what turns the right margin into booked, billable work.
What changes when AI agents handle the quoting and follow up?
AI agents are software that do a job the way you would do it yourself, using your own prices, your own wording and your own rules, not a generic template. For a waterproofing business, AI agents can draft the balcony or basement quote using your actual margin rules the moment the enquiry comes in, so good, better, best options go out the same day instead of sitting until there is time between site visits.
A second use for AI agents is chasing quotes that have gone quiet, following up the builder or tiler who asked for a basement tanking price and has not come back, without it falling to whoever is free in the office that week. That frees you, the waterproofer, and whoever else is on the tools, to spend the day on the membrane, the flood test, the inspection and the crew, rather than chasing paperwork between jobs.
Does the season change which work to chase?
Yes, and it is worth watching closely. Waterproofing work generally lifts through the building and renovation season, when bathroom and wet area jobs, balcony recoats and new basement tanking all come through builders and tilers at once. The cash can look good through that stretch, but the activity statement that lands after the peak is often the moment a waterproofing business finds out whether the work chased during the rush actually held its margin.
Balcony work through a builder often pays on progress claims, while basement and remedial work can sit until completion or until an insurance claim clears. Chasing the wrong mix for the season, even at a good margin on paper, can leave a waterproofing business waiting on money while tax is due. Checking the data on timing, not just margin, matters just as much here.
Should every balcony or basement lead get chased the same way?
No. Leads from builders and tilers who send repeat work are worth a different kind of follow up to a one-off homeowner enquiry for a leaking shower. A tracked referral circle with two or three builders or tilers per trade area, with a set follow up step logged after each job, keeps that relationship working both ways instead of it being a quiet hope that work comes back.
A one-off balcony or basement lead that goes quiet after a quote is worth a short, defined follow up sequence too, rather than being chased endlessly or dropped after one try. Treating every lead the same, whether it is a steady referral source or a single enquiry, is often where a waterproofer loses track of which relationships are actually worth protecting.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts with the waterproofing business's own numbers, not with a view on whether balcony or basement work is better. Greg Allan built his own trade business before building the Trade Business Intelligence, and the first thing it looks at here is margin by job type, at the point of quoting, alongside how quotes are followed up and how referral relationships with builders and tilers are actually tracked.
That usually shows where the real problem sits, whether that is a pricing gap on one job type, a follow up step that quietly stopped happening, or a season where cash and tax timing were never lined up. The how is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member who is open minded, innovative and willing to share what they learn.

