By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Why does an apprentice as a first hire slow a locksmith business down?
Most locksmith owners weighing up a first hire think an apprentice is the cheaper, safer start. It usually does the opposite. An apprentice cannot be left alone on a deadlock change, a master key cut or a restricted key job, so the owner still has to be there for every one of them, and the wage saving gets eaten by the owner's time.
The business that hires an apprentice first often finds the owner more stretched, not less. Every callout, every quote, every after hours lockout still needs the owner's hands or eyes on it. The crew has grown on paper, but the work the owner can personally get through has not.
What happens to restricted key jobs and after hours callouts while training someone from scratch?
Restricted key systems need traceable authority and careful record keeping, access control installs need someone who can read wiring and software without guessing, and a safe job often needs judgement built from doing it before. An apprentice on these jobs is watching, not running them, so what used to take one experienced locksmith now takes two people and the same amount of time.
After hours emergency work makes this worse. A locksmith cannot send an apprentice alone to a lockout at midnight, so the owner is still the one getting out of bed. The crew has grown, but the business is no further ahead on the jobs that pay the bills or the hours the owner actually gets back.
Why should the first hire be a qualified locksmith?
Your first hire into any key role in the business has to be experienced, because you do not have the spare time or attention to train someone unskilled properly while still running quotes, callouts and the books. A qualified locksmith can turn up to a rekey, a lock change or a commercial security door job and run it without you standing over them in the first week.
This is the hire that breaks the ceiling of being the only set of hands on restricted key work, access control installs and after hours callouts. The number that tells the truth here is not what an apprentice costs on paper. It is how many of last month's restricted key jobs, access control installs and after hours callouts needed you there in person, set against the strata and commercial quotes sitting unchased because there was nobody else who could run a job solo.
What changes once a qualified locksmith can run jobs solo?
Picture a locksmith business that has been running two qualified locksmiths on the tools, a costly way to staff rekeys and lock changes that one experienced person could handle alone. Restructured so one qualified locksmith works alongside a second-year apprentice instead of a second qualified locksmith, the business still covers the same jobs, but the apprentice is now learning restricted key work and access control from someone experienced, not from an owner who is already split between quoting, invoicing and emergency callouts.
Greg's sequence is to hire for skill and attitude first, so that when an apprentice comes on later they have an experienced locksmith to learn the trade from. An owner who hires the apprentice first often finds they cannot then afford the qualified hire, and the business stays capped at whatever one person can carry.
How does an AI agent fit in once you hire?
An AI agent is software that does a piece of office work the way you would do it, with your prices, your wording and your rules. Once a qualified locksmith is running jobs solo, an AI agent can take on the quoting follow up for strata and property manager work, the after hours roster, and the invoicing that used to sit in a pile at the end of the week.
That matters because it is data first, not guesswork, that shows which jobs are actually worth the owner's time once there is another set of hands. An AI agent handling the non-billable admin means the qualified locksmith's hours go on rekeys, access control and commercial jobs, and the owner's hours go on growing the accounts that pay best, rather than chasing paperwork from the van.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts from the owner's own numbers through the Trade Business Intelligence, not from a guess about what an apprentice would cost. For a locksmith weighing up a first hire, that means looking at which jobs, restricted key, access control, after hours, actually needed the owner last month, and where that time could instead go to quoting and growth if someone experienced could run a job alone.
Greg Allan built his own locksmith and security business before coaching others, and he is open about getting his own first hire wrong. “I hired an apprentice first. And then I couldn't grow.” The how, working through a locksmith's own hiring sequence, is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member who is open minded, innovative and willing to share.

