By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Should a fencing business hire a qualified fencer or an apprentice first?
A fencing business putting on its first hire is almost always better served by a qualified fencer who can run a boundary fence, pool fence or rural job solo, not an apprentice who needs supervision at the auger and on the footings. The owner rarely has the hours free to train someone properly while quoting and running the crew.
Put an apprentice in as the first hire and the business usually stays capped at what one experienced set of hands can produce, because the owner is still the one holding the auger, checking the footing and signing off every panel before the job can move on.
Why does hiring an apprentice first stall a fencing business?
Most fencing businesses start as one person doing everything: quoting the boundary fence, running the auger, setting steel posts, sorting the dividing fence split with the neighbour and loading the trailer each morning. Bring on an apprentice as the first hire and little changes, because the owner still has to supervise every post hole and footing.
That supervision eats exactly the hours the owner needed to free up. A fencing business can end up with two people on the job and barely more output than the owner working alone, once the training time is counted. The quoting backlog grows and the dividing fence negotiations get put off, and the business stays sized to what one person on the tools can carry.
What does an apprentice actually need on a pool fence or boundary fence job?
An apprentice fencer needs direct oversight on post spacing, plumb and footing depth, and close checking on the compliance detail around a pool fence or a gate that has to close and latch correctly every time. None of that can be handed over and left unattended.
A rural fencing run with long lines of steel post and strainers, or a chain mesh, paling or slat job against an awkward retaining line, asks for judgement an apprentice has not built yet. Without an already qualified fencer on site to carry that job, the owner becomes the one supervising, which puts them back on the tools instead of in front of the next quote or the next customer.
What should a fencing business look for in its first hire?
Your first hire should be a fencer who can take a boundary fence, pool fence or rural job from the quote through to the last panel and walk off site without you checking it. That is what actually frees your week for quoting, pricing variations and running more than one job at a time.
Skill and attitude together matter more at this stage than the wage gap between an apprentice and a qualified fencer, because the business cannot yet afford to carry someone who needs managing.
The number worth watching here is not the pay difference. It is how many hours you, the owner, are spending on the tools each week versus quoting and running the business. Memory makes the current split feel manageable; the actual hours in your diary or job records usually tell a different story, and that split is what should decide which hire comes first.
AI agents, software that does a job the way you would, with your own prices, wording and rules, can take on quote follow up and job scheduling once there is a fencer on the tools experienced enough to free you from supervising an apprentice at the post hole.
How does a qualified fencer free you up to quote and run more jobs?
With a fencer who can run a job solo, you can be measuring up the next dividing fence, pricing a pool fence and gate package, or sorting materials and the trailer load for tomorrow's rural job, instead of standing over a post hole. Two people are producing billable work at once rather than one producing and one training.
This is also where AI agents can start handling the non-billable office work, the supplier ordering, the scheduling, and the follow up on quotes sitting in the inbox, because there is finally a second set of experienced hands on the tools worth freeing up for.
Decided data first rather than on a feeling, the call becomes straightforward: look at what a week on the tools alone is producing against what two people, one of them experienced, could produce, and let that number choose the hire.
When does it make sense to bring on an apprentice?
Once a qualified fencer is carrying jobs solo, an apprentice becomes a genuine add to the business rather than a drag on it, because there is finally someone on site experienced enough to teach them without stopping the job.
Picture a fencing business that had been running two qualified fencers side by side on every job, which was a costly way to staff the work since two full wages were going onto jobs that did not always need two sets of experienced hands. The owner restructured the crew so one qualified fencer now works alongside a second-year apprentice instead of a second qualified fencer, with the apprentice learning the post hole and footing work under someone who can still carry the job solo if needed.
That is the safer order for a first key hire in a fencing business: experienced first, apprentice second, never the other way round.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts from the owner's own numbers through the Trade Business Intelligence rather than a feeling about whether the business is ready to hire. For a fencing business, that means looking at what the owner's week on the tools is actually producing against what a qualified fencer could produce running jobs solo, and where the quoting and admin hours are really going. Greg Allan is direct about getting this order wrong, having said “I hired an apprentice first. And then I couldn't grow,” and his advice for a first hire in any key role is to “make sure they're experienced first.” The how, working through the owner's own numbers to decide the hire, is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member who is open minded, innovative and willing to share.

