By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Why does a locksmith's gross profit look fine on average but hide losing jobs?
A locksmith running lockouts, rekeys, master key systems and commercial access control installs in the same week is really running several different cost structures at once. When the software, or the spreadsheet it replaces, blends them into one average gross profit figure, that figure can look healthy while individual jobs quietly lose money underneath it.
The jobs most likely to be losing money without anyone noticing are the small ones squeezed between the bigger ones: the after hours lockout, the one off rekey on a tenant change, the key cutting job that took longer than it should have. Documenting labour against each of those jobs by hand is manageable, but it is genuinely time consuming, and that is exactly the gap where costs get lumped together instead of tracked against the job that actually used them.
A locksmith working from a ruler and pencil to total up hours on a quote, or typing hours into a spreadsheet after the fact, is doing the same manual process in a different format. The time it takes is only half the problem. The real cost is what never gets captured at all: the extra twenty minutes on a stubborn deadlock, the second trip to the van for a part, the restricted key stock pulled for a job and never booked against it.
Why doesn't most booking or job management software fix this?
Most off the shelf job management software built for trades is designed to schedule a van, send a quote and raise an invoice. It is rarely built to separate labour time, key blanks, restricted key stock and hardware cost against the specific job that used them, which means every transaction still has to be manually entered and categorised before the owner can see which job type is actually paying.
That manual categorising is where cost of sales gets bundled into the wrong bucket. A master key system install that used three hours of programming time and a box of restricted key blanks can end up costed the same as a straightforward lock change, because the software was never built to ask the question. The owner ends up with a gross profit figure for the month that is technically correct and practically useless for deciding what to quote next time.
This is true whether the business is a sole operator locksmith doing residential lockouts and key cutting, or a commercial locksmith running access control installs for strata and property managers alongside emergency callouts. The cost structures are different. The reporting usually is not.
What's the best software for a locksmith business?
The best software for your locksmith business is whichever one captures what each callout actually costs, not whichever one has the nicest booking calendar. That means labour time, key cutting and blanks, restricted key stock, and hardware on access control and digital lock installs all booked against the right job, every time, without you having to chase it up.
You can rent software built for every trade at once, and for some locksmiths parts of that software genuinely earn their place, particularly for straightforward scheduling and invoicing. The honest answer is that your own data shows you which parts are worth keeping and which are costing you visibility rather than saving you time. That is a decision made from what your jobs actually look like, not from a feature list.
The alternative is owning systems shaped around how your jobs run: how a lockout gets quoted over the phone, how a rekey on a strata property gets priced against the real estate agent's expectations, how a commercial access control job gets costed against hardware and programming time. Built on your own data, those systems answer the question generic software was never asked.
How do AI agents change the office work for a locksmith?
An AI agent is software that does a piece of office work the way you would do it yourself, with your prices, your wording and your rules. For a locksmith, that can mean the non-billable admin around every callout, quote and invoice, done consistently, so you and your crew spend the time on the job in front of you instead of on paperwork behind it.
This matters most where locksmith work is least standard. An emergency lockout at two in the morning, a rekey booked through a property manager, a quote for a security door on a commercial unit: each has its own pricing logic and its own paperwork trail. An AI agent working data first, from the actual costs on your own jobs, can hold that logic consistently across every callout, so the quote for a Saturday night lockout reflects what a Saturday night lockout really costs, not a rough guess carried over from last time.
AI agents are not about replacing the locksmith on the job. They are about removing the office work that sits between finishing a callout and knowing whether it was worth doing.
Should you keep or replace the job management software you already use?
That depends on what your own data shows, not on what the software promises. Some locksmiths find their existing booking and invoicing tool works well enough for scheduling and should stay. Others find it was never built to separate labour, key cutting and hardware cost by job, and that gap is costing more than the software saves.
Picture a locksmith whose job management software has never opened up access to its own data. For six months the owner asked for a proper export of labour hours and material cost by job, and nothing changed. Rather than keep waiting, the owner has started building the business its own system, with the dashboards for job costing already working. The plan is to run it alongside the old software for now, move the crew across once they are comfortable with it, and switch the old system off only when it is no longer needed.
That is not a decision to cancel everything overnight. It is a decision to stop waiting for software built for every trade to answer a question only a locksmith's own numbers can answer.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts with the owner's own numbers through the Trade Business Intelligence, not with a list of software to try. For a locksmith, that usually means looking first at whether labour, key cutting and hardware cost are actually sitting against the right job, because that is where gross profit stops being honest and starts hiding losing callouts inside a healthy looking average.
Greg Allan, who built his own trade business before coaching others, puts it plainly from his own experience setting this up by hand: “Documenting labour against jobs, all that sort of stuff, which, yeah, I found it's very tricky.” The how, working out where your own numbers are hiding the real problem and building the system to fix it, is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member for every member, and that makes who joins matter.

