By Greg Allan, tradesman and creator of Data First Coaching
Why do good operators keep leaving earthmoving businesses?
Most earthmoving contractors put it down to wages, or a thin pool of licensed operators in their area. That is rarely where it starts. A good operator can feel when the business around them is guessing, when a site cut runs long and nobody knows if the day was profitable, when the float between jobs eats the morning and nobody accounted for it.
An operator who turns up every day to work that feels disorganised, underpriced or unstable eventually leaves for a business that seems to have its act together, even if the pay is similar. The business that loses operators is usually the one that cannot show them steady, well costed work through the quieter months, not just the one paying the least.
Is the real problem wages, or the way the business counts hours?
For most earthmoving contractors, it is the second one. An excavator or bobcat sitting on a float, waiting out a wet day, or booked into servicing is still costing wages, fuel and plant finance, but it is not earning a dollar on site. If the business cannot separate billable machine hours from total hours paid, every job absorbs a slice of cost that has nothing to do with that job.
That makes site cuts, trenching and bulk earthworks all look tighter than they are, which pushes owners toward cutting operator pay, chasing cheaper dry hire, or quoting lower to win work, all of which make keeping a good operator harder, not easier.
What does it actually cost to put an operator on the machine for a day?
You need one number before any hiring or retention decision: billable machine hours against total hours paid, including float, wet days and servicing. That is the number that tells you what an operator truly costs the business and what they earn it back, rather than a guess based on the invoice you sent the civil contractor last month.
Picture an earthmoving contractor who could never get an honest cost of operations figure. Every job looked unprofitable once overhead was spread across it, because non-billable hours, float, wet days, servicing, were loaded onto whatever job happened to be running that week. Stripping those hours out the other way made the figure look far too low to be real. Neither number was the truth. An AI agent, software that does a task the way the owner would, with their own wages, overheads and rules, pulled the actual wages and overhead straight from the business's live data and worked out the true cost of operations with billable hours properly factored in. Overhead now sits in its own bucket instead of being spread thin across every job, and the agent keeps that costing current as the business changes.
That is a data first way to answer a wages and hiring question, because it starts from what the business actually spent and earned, not from memory of a tough week.
How do you hire an operator with intent instead of under pressure?
You hire slowly, checking two things before you make an offer: can this person run the excavator or bobcat the way your sites need it run, and will they fit the crew you already have. Filling a seat because a tipper is sitting idle or a civil customer is chasing a start date almost always costs more later than waiting another week or two for the right fit.
An earthmoving contractor who hires under site pressure tends to repeat the same cycle: a quick hire, a few months of friction, a resignation, and the search starts again with less time than before. Hiring with intent breaks that cycle because it is built on the true cost figure, not on who is available this week.
What keeps a good operator once you've hired them?
A good operator stays where there is a structure around them, not just a machine and a job list. That means clear information on what each job needs, honest costing so they are not being pushed to cut corners on rock breaking or drainage work to hit an unrealistic margin, and a plan for the quiet months so wet weather or a slow season does not turn into a stood down roster with no notice.
Earthmoving contractors who keep their best operators longest are usually the ones who can show them, with real numbers, that the business knows what it is doing through fuel costs, tipping fees, servicing schedules and the wet hire versus dry hire decisions that affect everyone's hours.
Can AI agents actually help with this, or is it just more software?
AI agents can take on the ongoing, non-billable tracking that most earthmoving contractors never get to: keeping machine hours, float time, servicing and wet days updated against wages as the weeks go by, instead of a one-off calculation done at tax time. An agent does this the owner's way, using their own prices, their own crew and their own rules, so the figure stays true as fuel costs or servicing schedules change.
That frees the owner to spend time with the operator and the crew instead of buried in spreadsheets, which is its own part of keeping a good operator around.
How does Data First Coaching approach this?
Data First Coaching starts from the earthmoving contractor's own numbers through the Trade Business Intelligence, not from a conversation about wages or advertising. The first thing looked at is billable machine hours against total hours paid, because that is usually where the real problem with hiring and keeping operators starts, not where it shows up. Greg Allan teaches owners to “higher slowly, fire quickly, higher slowly, higher with intent” and to keep good operators by “building a foundation of support” around them. The how of building that costing and that support is worked through inside the Academy, with members, because the Trade Business Intelligence is powered by every member who is open minded, innovative and willing to share what they learn.

